The difference between cunning and cleverness in the hobbit by jrr tolkien

However, Tolkien does have a little to say on the matter To the editor of the 'Observer' And why dwarves? Grammar prescribes dwarfs; philology suggests that dwarrows would be the historical form.

The difference between cunning and cleverness in the hobbit by jrr tolkien

Prologue Smaug attacks Erebor. These events are related by the narrator, Gandalf and Thorin during the "unexpected party" at Bilbo's home. It is dramatically essential to show the audience just what is at stake, especially since the audience will not have another opportunity to see the story's main adversary, Smaug, until the second film.

Showing these events also adds scope and sweep to the story. Dramatizing these scenes require the writers to invent details that Tolkien did not describe. Second Prologue Frodo with invitation acceptance letters for Bilbo's birthday party. Such scenes would be fondly remembered by fans of the Lord of the Rings trilogy and put them in a good frame of mind for experiencing the rest of the film.

Frodo's appearance adds nothing to the story of Bilbo's adventures and serves only to make audiences wonder when the movie will actually get started. Much like how The Return of the King was criticized for having two many endings, this movie suffers from too many beginnings.

The difference between cunning and cleverness in the hobbit by jrr tolkien

It is sufficient that Bilbo discover his adventurous Tookish blood. Dwarves' Arrival Dwarves fall in through Bilbo's open door. Dwalin is the first to arrive, followed by Balin, Fili and Kili, and then Gandalf with the remainder of the dwarves, except for Thorin, who doesn't arrive until later in the evening.

As the dwarves greet one another, they say they haven't seen each other in some time. Having the dwarves meet up at Bilbo's home from apparently separate destinations emphasizes that they are a wandering people.

Thorin's late appearance also is a more dramatic arrival. It can be assumed that Gandalf had also arranged for the dwarves arrival at Bilbo's home for similar reasons.

As the dwarves arrive at Bag-End, they are described as follows: Dwalin has a blue beard and a dark-green hood; Balin has a white beard and scarlet hood; Kili and Fili each have yellow beards and blue hoods; Dori, Nori, Ori, Oin and Gloin have two purple hoods, a grey hood, a brown hood and a white hood; Bifur, Bofur and Bombur have two yellow hoods and a pale green one; and Thorin is wearing a sky-blue hood with a long silver tassel.

The lack of hoods allow viewers to differentiate the dwarves through their hair and beard styling without resorting to bright clothing colors that would detract from the rest of the scene. These changes done for the sake of realism is an unnecessary departure from what is supposed to be a children's story.

Thorin and the dwarves present Bilbo with a lengthy contract for his burglar services. A lengthy note is a more humorous prop, suggesting all the complications and dangers that await Bilbo.

Bilbo departs without even a pocket hankerchief. It is not reasonable that Bilbo would go off on a long journey without bringing travel items. The only reasonable explanation for Bilbo going off on such a journey should have been that he was pressured into it and left without thinking, as in the book.

The original scene within the Green Dragon would have been more enjoyable for movie-goers who remember the location from the Lord of the Rings films.

Betting on Bilbo Film: As they ride out of Hobbiton, Bilbo learns that the dwarves had bet Gandalf that Bilbo would not show up to go with them. There is no equivalent passage. This scene adds some welcome humor. This new material takes screentime that would be better devoted to scenes found in the book.

Gandalf Argues with Thorin Gandalf and Thorin have an argument. While in some shelter during a rain, Gandalf gets into an argument with Thorin and leaves.A summary of Themes in J. R. R.

Tolkien's The Hobbit. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of The Hobbit and what it means.

The Complete List of Film Changes

Perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans. Mar 02,  · Tolkien believed that orc may have been an Old English translation for demon and contended that the usage of goblin was a translation of this word in The Hobbit; which conincides eloquently with the translation being Elvish.

search essay examples. browse by category. browse by type. Get Expert. Essay Editing Help An Analysis of Bilbo Baggins in The Hobbit by JRR Tolkien.

words. 2 pages. A Review of The Hobbit by J.R.R. Tolkien. words. 2 pages. The Fantasy World That Has Differences in the Hobbit by J.R.R. Tolkien. words. 2 pages. Comparing and. In all honesty, I’d have to say JRR Tolkien. Both of the writers’ famed series are interesting enough and well-written enough to be read multiple times.

From the SparkNotes Blog

I first read The Lord of the Rings 30 years ago, and have probably read the series around 20 times now. Pro: This scene provides An Unexpected Journey with a resolution, as Thorin finally comes to respect Bilbo for the hobbit's bravery.

Con: The subplot involving Azog seeking revenge on Thorin is an unnecessary detail to add to what is supposed to be a children's story.

Tolkien’s other works include The Hobbit and The Simarillion, which are both available on audio from Random House. About J.R.R. Tolkien J.R.R. Tolkien was born on January 3, in South Africa.

Orc or goblin? is there a difference? | The Tolkien Forum